Karthigai Remarks by Great Madan
  • Dear Madan,

    Excellent analysis and remarks. It is an experiment for
    writing a historical novel. I will rectify such deficiencies in the
    proposed historical novel.

    Thank your very much for your encouragement.

    Always Yours
    Dr L. Kailasam 


    Dear Sir,

       I read through Karthigai. Overall a wonderful story. I really enjoyed it....

       Some humble comments below:
      
    1. There seems to be some confusion in page three where anandan is
    waiting on the lake bund - where am not able to visualize where he is
    standing, where the kavalan comes from etc., Maybe just a jumble of
    otherwise meaningful sentences?


       2. Am surprised that Mayavan would release an accused, but not keep an eye on him letting him to travel to the capital.
       3. Why should there be an attempt to portray mayavan as trying to mete out justice when in essence he is not fair minded?


       4. The spy from nowhere and no other purpose (or is he spying on mayavan - not clear) doesnt sit well
       5. Rajendra chola asking the spy to keep his predictions to himself is a great gesture - adds vitality to the character


       6. Karthigai's mother seems to be a purposeful insertion at the end
       7. You could have experimented with some more depth with the mayavan character.

       Looking forward to your novel. All the best!

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Top Posters