some contradictions ?Manimegalai
  • I had the same doubt when I Read Vengaiin Mainthan...but there aren't
    any evidence both to the fact he was ekapathiniviradan or he had more
    than one wife..
    When discussing among friends one thought was the second woman in his
    life is Manimegalai who he uses to befreind nandhini and save Aditha
    karikalan initially who finally gives her life for his love....
    In ponniyin selvan he ends with the statement..you wont see the
    chirpy ,cheeky vandiyadevan anymore..he will be more composed and
    mature..and Manimekaladeivam will be with him forever...

    So that could be the other woman.





    > hi everybody,
    >
    > Though I don't clearly know the reasons, i have more
    affinity towards sivakami-in sabatham. But i also love PS , Parthiban
    Kanavu and Vengain Mainthan(Akilan).
    >
    > I have a small doubt. I liked the character of
    vandhiya devan very much bcos he is a dynamic person to whom many
    females are attracted. But what made him great was that he never fell
    for anybody except ofcourse, Kundavai. That was great. But, in Vegai-
    in Mainthan, there will be a dialogue in which Illango will say to
    vandhiya devan,"Mama, i don't know how u managed with 2 wives". so,
    was vandhiya devan married only to kundavai or was there any other
    person in his life?
    >
    > Also, i would like to know more abt the places
    specified in PS and the historical facts. Like the kalvettu in the
    Thanjavur temple. Have any one of u visited it? Bye for now
    >
    >
    >
    > Bye
    >
    >
    >
    > "Truly great friends are hard to find, difficult to leave, and
    impossible to forget."
    >
    >
    >
    > ---------------------------------
    > Do You Yahoo!?
    > Yahoo! - Official partner of 2002 FIFA World Cup
  • Vanakkam,

    Though i'm not that good in history, i had read PS quite a number of
    times that i could recall Vandiya's romantic thoughts other than
    Kundavai, like when he first saw Manimegalai, he was thinking of
    asking Kandamaran abt her (though he considers her as his sister,
    after Maran says abt his plans of her engagment with some royal
    person). Then he meets Kundavai and falls completely for her (as the
    plan of Karikal had worked well). He feels somewhat attracted towards
    Nandini, but recovers himself from that feeling.
    Later when he meets Poonguzhali, he starts his romantic talks (in his
    dreams) only to keep himself restrained by reminding of her nature and
    that she was born for Sendhan.
    I think Kalki would have wanted to show him as more human than
    anyother character in PS, mainly Arumozhi. What we had/are/will be
    discussing are mostly Kalki's point of view, and not the sole truth.
    Hence, we can't come to a conclusion.

    As for as the 2nd wife of Vandiya, i'm not aware as i haven't yet read
    Vengaiyin Maindan. But, i think he could have even mentioned about
    Vandiya's job, as Vandiya is a kind of person to boost about his job
    being his first wife, if you could catch what i'm trying to say ;)

    Nandrigaludan,
    Amar

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Top Posters